HISTORY: A Federal Court Ruled College Cheer Could Not Count as a Sport
The 2010 Quinnipiac ruling rocked the industry, but it paved the way for A&T and STUNT to secure NCAA championship status. We break down the legal battle that redefined cheer as a varsity powerhouse.
Shane James
Founder, Cheer Media
Published
Read Time6 Min Read
Views 321
Photo by Quinnipiac Sideline Cheer
The 2010 Quinnipiac ruling centered on Title IX, varsity participation and the structure of competitive cheer. Acrobatics & Tumbling and STUNT later addressed many of the problems identified by the court.
On July 21, 2010, a federal court ruled that Quinnipiac University could not count its women’s competitive cheerleading team as a varsity sport for Title IX compliance.
The decision quickly generated a much broader headline: Cheerleading is not a sport.
That description omitted the central issue in the case.
U.S. District Judge Stefan R. Underhill did not rule that cheerleaders were not athletes or that competitive cheer lacked athletic difficulty. He ruled that Quinnipiac’s program did not meet the federal standard for a legitimate varsity athletic participation opportunity.
The distinction shaped the next era of college cheer.
Quinnipiac cuts women’s volleyball
The case began in March 2009 when Quinnipiac announced that it would eliminate women’s volleyball, men’s golf and men’s outdoor track and field.
The university also announced plans to establish women’s competitive cheerleading as a varsity program.
Quinnipiac intended to count the competitive cheer team’s 30 roster positions among the athletic opportunities it provided to women. Those positions helped the university’s Title IX participation numbers.
Five volleyball players—Stephanie Biediger, Kayla Lawler, Erin Overdevest, Kristen Corinaldesi and Logan Riker—joined head coach Robin Sparks in filing a lawsuit against the university.
They argued that Quinnipiac would deny women equal varsity participation opportunities by eliminating volleyball. They also challenged the university’s decision to count competitive cheer as a varsity sport under Title IX.
The court agreed.
The Title IX calculation
Title IX prohibits sex-based discrimination in education programs receiving federal funding. In college athletics, schools must provide equal athletic opportunities for male and female students.
Schools have multiple ways to demonstrate compliance. One is to provide athletic participation opportunities that are substantially proportionate to undergraduate enrollment.
Women represented 61.87% of Quinnipiac’s undergraduate enrollment during the period examined by the court. The court determined that women received 58.25% of the university’s recognized varsity participation opportunities.
That produced a gap of 3.62 percentage points.
The court also examined Quinnipiac’s roster management. The university had increased roster targets for some women’s teams, restricted men’s rosters and counted certain women’s cross-country athletes again in indoor and outdoor track.
The competitive cheer roster became a major part of the case.
If the court counted those 30 athletes, Quinnipiac moved closer to proportionality. If it excluded them, the university remained short of the participation opportunities needed to support its Title IX position.
Why competitive cheer did not qualify
The case was not decided by measuring the difficulty of tumbling passes, baskets or partner stunts.
The court evaluated how Quinnipiac’s program operated.
Competitive cheer was not recognized by the NCAA as a championship or emerging sport. The activity also lacked consistent rules, standardized scoring, a defined season and an established postseason system.
Quinnipiac competed in events that used different formats. Opponents did not always follow the same rules or scoring systems. Some events did not function like direct varsity competition between colleges.
Underhill concluded that competitive cheer was “too underdeveloped and disorganized” to provide genuine varsity athletic participation opportunities at that time.
The ruling applied to Quinnipiac’s program and the Title IX evidence presented in 2010. It was not a universal finding that every form of cheerleading lacked the qualities of a sport.
College administrators and coaches were already working to establish a varsity sport using skills from cheerleading and gymnastics before the court issued its July decision.
Azusa Pacific, Fairmont State and Quinnipiac were interested in converting existing competitive cheer programs. Baylor and Oregon planned to add a new women’s varsity sport.
The first collegiate Acrobatics & Tumbling meet took place in 2010.
The original group included Azusa Pacific University, Baylor University, Fairmont State University, the University of Maryland, the University of Oregon and Quinnipiac University.
Administrators from those schools formed the National Collegiate Acrobatics & Tumbling Association during summer 2010.
That timeline is significant. Acrobatics & Tumbling was not created after the Quinnipiac ruling. Competition had already started, and Quinnipiac was one of the six original programs.
A&T established a uniform meet structure with six events: compulsory, acro, pyramid, toss, tumbling and team event. Each skill receives a difficulty value, with judges scoring execution.
Oregon won the first NCATA national championship in April 2011.
USA Gymnastics added Acrobatics & Tumbling as a discipline in 2013. The NCAA added it to the Emerging Sports for Women program in all three divisions in August 2020.
USA Cheer developed STUNT as a separate sport using technical elements of cheerleading.
Methodist University and the University of North Carolina participated in the first STUNT scrimmage in December 2010. Approximately 30 coaches attended the event in Fayetteville, North Carolina.
The first STUNT tournament followed on Jan. 29, 2011, in Louisville, Kentucky. Louisville, Morehead State and West Virginia competed.
Twenty college programs participated during the inaugural 2011 season.
STUNT uses a head-to-head game format divided into four quarters: partner stunts, pyramids and tosses, jumps and tumbling, and team routine.
Teams perform prescribed routines simultaneously. Officials compare execution and award points by round.
The documented competition dates establish the order:
DevelopmentAcrobatics & TumblingSTUNTFirst college competition20102011First championshipApril 20112011NCAA Emerging Sports status20202023 in Divisions I and II; 2024 in Division IIINCAA championship statusJanuary 2026January 2026First NCAA championshipProjected for spring 2027Projected for spring 2027
Acrobatics & Tumbling competed first and reached NCAA Emerging Sports status three years before STUNT.
The sports are not interchangeable. They use different formats, scoring systems and governance structures.
Both, however, created varsity competition for athletes with backgrounds in cheerleading and gymnastics.
The ruling survives an appeal
Quinnipiac appealed the district court’s decision.
On Aug. 7, 2012, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit upheld the ruling. The appeals court agreed that Quinnipiac’s 30 competitive cheer roster positions could not be counted as genuine varsity athletic opportunities.
The court acknowledged that competitive cheer required strength, agility and grace. It still found that the activity presented in the case lacked the organization and defined rules necessary for Title IX recognition.
By then, Acrobatics & Tumbling and STUNT had completed their first seasons.
Acrobatics & Tumbling entered the NCAA Emerging Sports for Women program in 2020. STUNT followed in Divisions I and II in 2023 and Division III in 2024.
Both sports eventually surpassed the NCAA requirement of 40 sponsoring institutions meeting minimum participation and competition standards.
In January 2026, NCAA members approved Acrobatics & Tumbling and STUNT as championship sports. The first NCAA championships are projected for spring 2027.
The NCAA votes came more than 15 years after the Quinnipiac decision.
The court’s ruling addressed a competitive cheer program without uniform rules, consistent scoring or an established collegiate championship structure.
Acrobatics & Tumbling and STUNT now provide those elements through two separately governed sports. Both will award their first NCAA championships in 2027.